Page says "not found" but returns 200

HighHigh priority, in Content

Short answer

Page says "not found" but returns 200 means: the page tells visitors it doesn't exist, yet answers 200 OK. Google calls this a soft 404 and drops it, and visitors land on a dead end from search. To fix it: make missing pages return a real 404 (or 410), and redirect pages that moved to their new address.

By the SmooxSEO team. Updated on 16 November 2026.

What it means and why it matters

The page tells visitors it doesn't exist, yet answers 200 OK. Google calls this a soft 404 and drops it, and visitors land on a dead end from search.

How to fix it

Make missing pages return a real 404 (or 410), and redirect pages that moved to their new address.

Common causes

  • A "page not found" or "no results" page that answers with a 200 status instead of 404.
  • Deleted products or articles replaced by an empty template.
  • Every unknown address showing the home page or a search page.

How to spot it

Type a made-up address on your site (yourdomain.com/this-does-not-exist) and check the status in the browser's network tab: it should be 404. In Search Console, the Pages report lists "Soft 404" pages. SmooxSEO flags pages whose content says "not found" while the status says OK.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Redirecting all missing pages to the home page: Google treats those redirects as soft 404s too.
  • Keeping thousands of empty category or search pages indexable.

How to fix it on your platform

WordPress
Your theme's 404.php already returns 404; make sure plugins don't redirect missing pages to the home page.
JavaScript apps
For unknown routes, return a 404 status from the server, or add <meta name="robots" content="noindex"> to the "not found" view.

Questions people ask

Is a soft 404 a penalty?

No, but Google drops those pages from results and wastes crawl time on them. Return a real 404 or 410 for pages that don't exist.

How serious is it?

A page can't be found, indexed or trusted, or search engines can't read part of the site. Fix it soon: it costs traffic.

About content checks

Thin, duplicate or hard-to-read content, spelling and the depth of each page. Search engines and AI assistants favour pages that fully answer a question.

Find this problem on your site

SmooxSEO checks every page of your site for this problem and 311 others, lists the pages concerned, and tells you what to fix first.

Related content checks

All content checksAll 312 checks